site stats
Welcome, register | help | log in

Second E-pinion: Challenging the Definition of Medical Practice

Featured in:

This week's Washington Post has a story discussing patient's experience getting a second opinion on heart surgery via a remote "e-consultation" with Cleveland Clinic.

At this point, not many people have had direct experience with online second opinions and there are good reasons for this. The whole motivation behind doing things online is to make things easier. Unfortunately it appears that the current roadblocks to telemedicine are significant. Here is a shortlist:

  • Start-up Barriers: Only a few institutions, like Cleveland Clinic have resources to offer the service today. This excludes many quality doctors not affiliated with such centers. Technology must be made available to an average solo practitioner.
  • Paper Records: Sure, the second opinion is electronic and delivered online, but it has to be based on prior medical records, which are anything but. Obtaining the paper documents, scanning and faxing is a significant burden, subtracting from the experience.
  • Antiquated Laws: Many states make telemedicine technically illegal or restrict it beyond reasonable. The stated motivation is to protect the patient from risk (of course!), but in reality medical boards are guarding their turf against interstate competition.
  • Cash Patients Only: You have to really want that second e-pinion, since your health plan most likely would not pay for it. Mohit Ghose of America's Health Insurance Plans, says they are "evaluating how patient privacy and other issues can be resolved before covering this Internet service".
  • Care Coordination: Your primary physician still has to be actively involved, while remote specialist may not even be made accessible on the phone. In the end you may be forced to choose whether to trust "the remote expert from a leading-edge institution" or "the doctor who knows my heart best".

While the challenges seem daunting, this example of a successful "second e-pinion" shows how medical practice is evolving. Healthcare, as politics, will continue to remain mostly a local affair, but more will be delivered remotely. Yet we cannot expect real adoption until:

  • Governments remove regulatory roadblocks
  • EMR becomes cheap, widespread and connected
  • Payors respond to the consumer demand

To read the story follow the link here.

Trackbacks (0)

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: http://trusted.md/trackback/1823

Comments (1)

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 12/08/2005 - 7:13pm.

Hello there, I hope you want to hear about Diary of a Medical Nightmare! and man oh man has it been one.  I had surgery @ Presbyterian Hospital in Charlotte, N. C. where all my blood was replaced with "blood substitues".  It rearranged my insides (organs) including my brain.  You know our body is dependant on oxygen and since the hetastarch and lactated ringers I was given carry no oxygen,  I have been suffering a slow death over thepast five years.  I never would have known what happened had one of my doctors told me "they had really messed me up" and asked me how much did you bleed .  This started my research.  I have dealth with the hospital as we;; as the FDA and it is terrifying to know haw little the FDA does to protect us from the dangers of drugs.  If you have had surgery, get your medical records.  Of utmost importance is an itemized statement of your bill.  This is where I discovered Presbyterian had falsefied my records.  The IV drugs and meds did not come even close to what my medical records indicated was given to tme.  I have tired to get a diagnosis for five years and now Baptist Hospital in Winston Salem, N. C. tells me they will not discuss the results of my brain CT with me.  They have refused to discuss my questions or meet with me to review test results in spite of the HIPAA Act as well as the Patient Bill of Rights .  I am so sick and feel as thought I have no where to turn.  The FDA has said it will not go public (the fact that blood substitutes are being used) I have letters from them and a copy of a mandate that the Drug companies find an alternative to blood.  Wonder who is Washington is a Jehovah Wittness??????

Post new comment

[?]
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Captcha Image: you will need to recognize the text in it.
[?]
Please type in the letters/numbers that are shown in the image above.

User login